Kirk Cousins (Traded to Vikings)

Las Vegas Raiders Discussion.
Born from RF.net ruins, resurrected as RF.com, now arriving at Raiderstation.
The #1 Las Vegas Raiders site on the web!
User avatar
Reno Hightower
Posts: 3,285
Joined: Sun Sep 08, 2024 4:59 pm
Has given High Fives: 854 times
Received High Fives: 1243 times

Kirk Cousins (Traded to Vikings)

Unread post by Reno Hightower »

I have rarely seen a QB do more with less. Kubiak has made it clear that he is the guy this year but his play has really defied conventional wisdom. The run blocking is as putrid as it was last season. The pass blocking has been getting compliments but how much as that has to do with Cousins's pocket presence and pre snap reads?

I am not sure the subject deserves its own thread but I think what he has accomplished this season cannot be overstated and he has essentially put the offense on his back. I don't think anyone saw this coming.

Thoughts?...
These users gave a High Five to the author Reno Hightower for the post (total 5):
Rabidraider, Steve007, mranquales, GoodTimeCharlie, Amish Cabal
User avatar
ALLRAIDERWORLD21
Posts: 4,238
Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2015 10:02 pm
Has given High Fives: 544 times
Received High Fives: 692 times

Unread post by ALLRAIDERWORLD21 »

Cruisin with Tooz wrote: Thu Nov 12, 2026 2:17 pm You mention the fact that Minn will absorb that 10 million of KCs deferred salary, as if they did us a favor that should lower the compensation. The guy has performed like a 50+ million/year QB.

Cousins: 20 TDs 8 Int Comp% 64.1 Total Yards 2340 Yrds/att 7.4 Sacks 11 Rate 97.1
Mahomes: 14 TD 4 Int Comp% 67.3 Total Yards 2037 Yrds/Att 7.7 Sacks 11 Rate 101.8
Allen: 12 TD 6 Int Comp% 66.1 Total Yards 2027 Yrds/Att 8.6 Sacks 17 Rate 99.3
Wentz: 3 TDs 2 Int Comp% 48.4 Total Yards 357 Yrds/att 7.4 Sacks 7 Rate 68.3 (in 3 games)

And this is without any semblance of a run game to share the load, and without a legitimate #1 WR.

For the 1/2 year they will have him, Minn will be expected to receive 25 million in expected on-the-field value. They will pay 10.66 million for that value. Therefore his contract has an expected net surplus value of more than 14 million dollars. They didnt do us any favor by paying next years 10 million. They did themselves a favor. They got a steal. Paying 10.66 million for 25 million in value is a steal. We did them the favor. We gave up the 15% chance we still had of making the playoffs and whatever else he could continue to contribute to Mendoza's further development, all to save their season. And they should have paid more for this, not less. You dont reduce your ask when you are giving the other party a steal. Spytek screwed the pooch by not standing firm and getting more value plus a conditional pick deal here. He still had another 75 minutes before the deadline to go eyeball to eyeball and let the pressure build. Not doing the trade was justifiable from our standpoint. It wasnt from their standpoint. Minn was the party without the leverage, because their season was going down the tubes. Minn wouldnt make the playoffs with Wentz. They will with Cousins.

I call bullshit on the trade evals giving Spytek an "A". More like an "F". A strong case based upon the work of Massey and Thaler can even be made that he should have obtained more than the 2nd round pick (or the better 3rd round pick) outright, PLUS the possibility of an upgraded pick. In addition to other things, we traded away 14.33 million in net surplus value, which is the delta between the on-the-field value for 1/2 year (25 million) and what we would have paid for it (10.66 million). For the moment ignoring everything else we gave up (15% shot at playoffs; mentoring Mendoza; and having a more capable backup than AOC), we should have at least obtained the equivalent in draft capital of 14.33 million of net surplus value. What did we get back? The expected net surplus value of pick 96 (scaled to 2026 cap dollars) is between 2.08 million/yr to 2.34 million/year. Over the course of a 4-yr rookie deal that is a total net surplus value of 8.32 to 9.36 million, far short of the 14.33 million we traded away. Picks 64 and picks 69 have virtually the same values. Over a 4 year rookie deal and scaled to 2026 cap dollars, those picks are worth a total between 12.5 and 13.5 million net surplus value, still less than what was given up. And this just sets the floor for what Spytek should have obtained. There should have been additional compensation for forgoing our shot at the playoffs; and for the loss of mentoring. And beyond that, there is the issue of leverage, which we had and which dictates prices, as much as intrinsic value does. Spytek was absolutely fleeced in this deal.
In 2-3 years it may be the Raiders needing that one piece to put them over the top and the Vikings may have that piece.. thats how it works sometimes..
User avatar
Cruisin with Tooz
Posts: 1,820
Joined: Sun Jun 23, 2024 11:43 am
Has given High Fives: 241 times
Received High Fives: 531 times

Unread post by Cruisin with Tooz »

ALLRAIDERWORLD21 wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 10:45 am In 2-3 years it may be the Raiders needing that one piece to put them over the top and the Vikings may have that piece.. thats how it works sometimes..
If that comes to pass, they wont be getting a sweetheart deal. The way it works is everyone tries to do what is in their own best interest.
User avatar
ELCAraiderfan
GhostMad StorkBig BenBowers
Posts: 3,436
Joined: Fri Sep 16, 2016 2:38 pm
Has given High Fives: 938 times
Received High Fives: 453 times

Unread post by ELCAraiderfan »

Vikings have got to be thinking to themselves, "What the hell were we thinking letting JJ go?"

Watching him in yesterday's game he looks like he's going to be a decent to good qb in the NFL. Wonder what changed him into a bust to a possible NFL caliber starting quarterback?

Wonder what the Giants are going to do with Dart and now JJ. Nice qb room for sure
User avatar
Atlasffa
Posts: 13,154
Joined: Sun May 01, 2016 7:41 am
Location: Just Win Baby!
Has given High Fives: 181 times
Received High Fives: 756 times

Unread post by Atlasffa »

Vikings has no more patience for JJ for these reasons (according to AI):

• Inconsistent On-Field Play: After missing his entire 2024 rookie season with a torn meniscus, McCarthy started 10 games in 2025, throwing for 1,632 yards with 11 touchdowns and 12 interceptions (35.6 QBR). His frenetic play style and mechanical issues failed to show the year-three jump the coaching staff wanted.
• Injuries and Durability Concerns: McCarthy suffered multiple injuries—including to his knee, ankle, concussion, and a right-hand hairline fracture—partly stemming from playing outside the pocket.
• Off-Field and Routine Issues: Reports highlighted that McCarthy struggled with day-to-day consistency, discipline, and the "boring stuff" required of a franchise quarterback. Tensions and communication lapses around injuries further strained behind-the-scenes dynamics.
• Win-Now Timeline: With a roster built to contend immediately, the Vikings pivoted to veteran options like Kyler Murray rather than waiting for McCarthy to mature, ultimately trading him to the Giants for a 2027 fifth-round pick.

Injury history:
• August 2024 (Knee): Suffered a torn meniscus in his right knee during his first NFL preseason with the Minnesota Vikings, forcing him to miss his entire rookie season.
• September 2025 (Ankle): Suffered a severe Grade 3 high ankle sprain in Week 2 against the Atlanta Falcons, sidelining him for multiple weeks.
• November 2025 (Concussion): Suffered a head concussion during a Week 12 game against the Green Bay Packers and missed the following game.
• December 2025 / January 2026 (Hand): Suffered a small hairline fracture in his throwing hand in Week 16, causing him to miss a game, and later aggravated the hand injury in Week 18.
• August 2026 (Ankle): Sustained a preseason ankle injury during training camp/preseason before being traded to the New York Giants.
• November 2026 (Hip): Suffered a hip pointer (deep bone bruise) after taking a hit in Week 9 against the Philadelphia Eagles. He briefly exited the game but returned to play and faced no injury designations going into Week 10.


I also read at the time that he has "personality" issues which were not detailed or explained. I think he just wasn't a fit for their culture and I doubt they regret the decision nor want him back.
User avatar
16 to 88
Posts: 19,238
Joined: Thu May 01, 2014 10:23 pm
Location: Dog House
Has given High Fives: 455 times
Received High Fives: 312 times

Unread post by 16 to 88 »

Atlasffa wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 4:25 pm Vikings has no more patience for JJ for these reasons (according to AI):

• Inconsistent On-Field Play: After missing his entire 2024 rookie season with a torn meniscus, McCarthy started 10 games in 2025, throwing for 1,632 yards with 11 touchdowns and 12 interceptions (35.6 QBR). His frenetic play style and mechanical issues failed to show the year-three jump the coaching staff wanted.
• Injuries and Durability Concerns: McCarthy suffered multiple injuries—including to his knee, ankle, concussion, and a right-hand hairline fracture—partly stemming from playing outside the pocket.
• Off-Field and Routine Issues: Reports highlighted that McCarthy struggled with day-to-day consistency, discipline, and the "boring stuff" required of a franchise quarterback. Tensions and communication lapses around injuries further strained behind-the-scenes dynamics.
• Win-Now Timeline: With a roster built to contend immediately, the Vikings pivoted to veteran options like Kyler Murray rather than waiting for McCarthy to mature, ultimately trading him to the Giants for a 2027 fifth-round pick.

Injury history:
• August 2024 (Knee): Suffered a torn meniscus in his right knee during his first NFL preseason with the Minnesota Vikings, forcing him to miss his entire rookie season.
• September 2025 (Ankle): Suffered a severe Grade 3 high ankle sprain in Week 2 against the Atlanta Falcons, sidelining him for multiple weeks.
• November 2025 (Concussion): Suffered a head concussion during a Week 12 game against the Green Bay Packers and missed the following game.
• December 2025 / January 2026 (Hand): Suffered a small hairline fracture in his throwing hand in Week 16, causing him to miss a game, and later aggravated the hand injury in Week 18.
• August 2026 (Ankle): Sustained a preseason ankle injury during training camp/preseason before being traded to the New York Giants.
• November 2026 (Hip): Suffered a hip pointer (deep bone bruise) after taking a hit in Week 9 against the Philadelphia Eagles. He briefly exited the game but returned to play and faced no injury designations going into Week 10.


I also read at the time that he has "personality" issues which were not detailed or explained. I think he just wasn't a fit for their culture and I doubt they regret the decision nor want him back.
As I wrote a page back, it makes me wonder about what is going on in Minnesota.

-They moved up to draft McCarthy in the 24 draft almost assuredly with O'Connell green lighting it.
-3 years later they acquire Murray to compete with McCarthy. Again, almost assuredly being endorsed by O'Connell.
-3 weeks in they ship off McCarthy and have Wentz as the primary back up.
-They roll with Murray knowing his injury history, size and what kind of QB he is. He's missed 2 games already this season.
-When Wentz comes in he is so bad they have to trade for Cousins which they coughed up a 3rd round pick for.
-Meanwhile McCarthy has to learn a whole new system and playbook and is looking like a capable QB in NY.

I see a lot of mistakes being made at the quarterback position. Not sure why they even so much as bothered with Murray who seems to have lost his job for the season when Cousins who is much more familiar with that offense was there for the taking in the off season. Yes, Cousins had a clear path to start for us but the vikings could have done the same with him and offered him the staring job and the contract we did and let McCarthy sit behind him and maybe learn. Murray signed for a 1 year deal vet minimum and the Cousins deal while significantly more would have meant they would still have a 3rd and maybe even be undefeated at this point.
User avatar
Atlasffa
Posts: 13,154
Joined: Sun May 01, 2016 7:41 am
Location: Just Win Baby!
Has given High Fives: 181 times
Received High Fives: 756 times

Unread post by Atlasffa »

16 to 88 wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 10:09 pm As I wrote a page back, it makes me wonder about what is going on in Minnesota.

-They moved up to draft McCarthy in the 24 draft almost assuredly with O'Connell green lighting it.
-3 years later they acquire Murray to compete with McCarthy. Again, almost assuredly being endorsed by O'Connell.
-3 weeks in they ship off McCarthy and have Wentz as the primary back up.
-They roll with Murray knowing his injury history, size and what kind of QB he is. He's missed 2 games already this season.
-When Wentz comes in he is so bad they have to trade for Cousins which they coughed up a 3rd round pick for.
-Meanwhile McCarthy has to learn a whole new system and playbook and is looking like a capable QB in NY.

I see a lot of mistakes being made at the quarterback position. Not sure why they even so much as bothered with Murray who seems to have lost his job for the season when Cousins who is much more familiar with that offense was there for the taking in the off season. Yes, Cousins had a clear path to start for us but the vikings could have done the same with him and offered him the staring job and the contract we did and let McCarthy sit behind him and maybe learn. Murray signed for a 1 year deal vet minimum and the Cousins deal while significantly more would have meant they would still have a 3rd and maybe even be undefeated at this point.
It was just meant for Kirk to be a Viking. They took the long way around and finally came the right decision. So weird how all the pieces meshed in just the right and wrong ways for him to land back where he belongs. :thinking: Fate will not be denied.
These users gave a High Five to the author Atlasffa for the post:
Reno Hightower
User avatar
Oaktownonly
Posts: 3,811
Joined: Sat Nov 01, 2014 9:32 am
Has given High Fives: 504 times
Received High Fives: 482 times

Unread post by Oaktownonly »

Kirk was the perfect guy to become a Raider. Fernando needed someone to show him the ropes about being a QB in the nfl and they both seemed to hit it off and become good friends. Fernando is way better off going into Sunday because of Cousin's. I will be rooting for Cousin's to continue his great year with the Vikings.
These users gave a High Five to the author Oaktownonly for the post (total 5):
Raiders Baby, Dr Death, Atlasffa, Xramfan, Willmark
User avatar
Atlasffa
Posts: 13,154
Joined: Sun May 01, 2016 7:41 am
Location: Just Win Baby!
Has given High Fives: 181 times
Received High Fives: 756 times

Unread post by Atlasffa »

Oaktownonly wrote: Sat Nov 14, 2026 8:33 am Kirk was the perfect guy to become a Raider. Fernando needed someone to show him the ropes about being a QB in the nfl and they both seemed to hit it off and become good friends. Fernando is way better off going into Sunday because of Cousin's. I will be rooting for Cousin's to continue his great year with the Vikings.
THE perfect guy to become a Raider--one of one. The stars aligned for Kirk, Fernando, Raiders and Vikings. And the irony of Kirk's first game back with the Vikings will be on the field where his first stint with them ended. Coincidence? It's all like a movie script that no one would believe happens in real life. It will be interesting to see how the rest of the story plays out... and hopefully we will like it.
These users gave a High Five to the author Atlasffa for the post (total 2):
Xramfan, Oaktownonly
User avatar
Attyla
Gold JacketSnake3 Mile LyleMad MaxFernando
Posts: 52,927
Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 4:31 pm
Has given High Fives: 1269 times
Received High Fives: 3063 times

Unread post by Attyla »

ESPN reporting the Vikes started with an offer of a 5th round. I am still thrilled with what we got.
User avatar
SkullCrusher
Posts: 12,059
Joined: Sun Dec 08, 2013 4:14 pm
Location: The Nation.
Has given High Fives: 504 times
Received High Fives: 639 times

Unread post by SkullCrusher »

ELCAraiderfan wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 2:40 pm Vikings have got to be thinking to themselves, "What the hell were we thinking letting JJ go?"
He seemed mentally gone in Minnesota. Shit happens both ways here.
User avatar
GoodTimeCharlie
Posts: 5,122
Joined: Tue Jan 14, 2020 6:26 pm
Location: Atop the commode
Has given High Fives: 1679 times
Received High Fives: 1727 times

Unread post by GoodTimeCharlie »

ELCAraiderfan wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 2:40 pm Vikings have got to be thinking to themselves, "What the hell were we thinking letting JJ go?"

Watching him in yesterday's game he looks like he's going to be a decent to good qb in the NFL. Wonder what changed him into a bust to a possible NFL caliber starting quarterback?

Wonder what the Giants are going to do with Dart and now JJ. Nice qb room for sure
Here’s my working theory. Harbaugh yells. KOC is a “QB whisperer”. JJ could never hear the instructions.

Yup
User avatar
ALLRAIDERWORLD21
Posts: 4,238
Joined: Thu Apr 30, 2015 10:02 pm
Has given High Fives: 544 times
Received High Fives: 692 times

Unread post by ALLRAIDERWORLD21 »

ELCAraiderfan wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 2:40 pm Vikings have got to be thinking to themselves, "What the hell were we thinking letting JJ go?"

Watching him in yesterday's game he looks like he's going to be a decent to good qb in the NFL. Wonder what changed him into a bust to a possible NFL caliber starting quarterback?

Wonder what the Giants are going to do with Dart and now JJ. Nice qb room for sure
He folded when Washington blitzed him in crunch time. An elite QB would have made them pay..
User avatar
BoKnows81
Bo Knows
Posts: 7,416
Joined: Sat Sep 12, 2015 3:36 am
Has given High Fives: 914 times
Received High Fives: 2070 times

Unread post by BoKnows81 »

NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport reports the Vikings have talked to Kirk Cousins “about returning to Minnesota for the 2027 season.”

Rapoport notes that the Vikings told Cousins they wanted him around beyond this year before their trade for him was complete. They would go on to pay a third-round pick to reunite with their former starter. Even if Cousins is far from a superstar quarterback, head coach Kevin O’Connell is clearly sick of the weekly carousel under center. The Vikings will be legitimate Super Bowl contenders if Cousins can just play as well as he did in Vegas. A deep playoff run will all but guarantee him a spot on the roster next year.
User avatar
chucker
Gold JacketThe JudgeBowersFernando
Posts: 17,257
Joined: Thu Dec 05, 2013 7:53 am
Has given High Fives: 2289 times
Received High Fives: 3021 times

Unread post by chucker »

Rough start for Cousins. 2 drives, both 3 and out. One pass complete for -4 yards. One sack.
User avatar
Attyla
Gold JacketSnake3 Mile LyleMad MaxFernando
Posts: 52,927
Joined: Wed Feb 05, 2014 4:31 pm
Has given High Fives: 1269 times
Received High Fives: 3063 times

Unread post by Attyla »

chucker wrote: Sun Nov 15, 2026 10:15 am Rough start for Cousins. 2 drives, both 3 and out. One pass complete for -4 yards. One sack.
Sack was ugly too. His target was just breaking and he did not feel the pressure
Post Reply