rich72 wrote: Tue Jul 21, 2026 1:14 pm
We dont even know what we have in Mendoza yet, he could suck for all we know. Wouldnt be the first time a #1 overall pick didnt live up to the hype. Lets just calm our jets and wait it out until we see what he can do against NFL level competition.
We know more than most think. This is not like in the day when all you could do is look at the tape. We have all sorts of advanced metrics to measure probability. Here is a short list of what we know
1. Intelligence, perhaps the number one trait that you can measure on the player and we know he is very intelligent
2. Character, we see this repeatedly in his life. Character, or moral compass is the thing that both Russell and Leaf did not have and the flags were there well ahead of time
3. Ability, we know he can make a large number of the throws and is accurate as hell
4. Stature, his frame is large and as he adds a bit of girth his frame will resemble that of Rothlesburger, and able to take a lot of hits
5. Speed, not a burner but a guy who sees holes and hits them when needed
6. Trainability. We saw that with the move from Cal to Indiana
7. Leadership, we have seen time and time again that he leads his players by both his example and humility
8. Work ethic. We saw that in many games where he did not enjoy the moment but was on the sidelines looking at film on the devices
What we do not know
1. Will he be able to absorb the pressure and hits at the next level. Make no mistake, he will be under extreme pressure as the number one pick
2. Will the speed of the game overwhelm him? Likely no due to his intelligence but it is a question for sure
3. Will he be able to work under center effectively? Certainly we brought in that exact center to help but it is not a certainty
4. Will he gel? This one is tricky simply because of number one and number two
5. Can he take the losses he will likely take early and not fold. Losing is certainly a disease and some never recover
There will be questions but we know a lot of things that are positives. The questions will take time but his intelligence and character are two traits I bet on every time when it comes to the position. It is why I developed quick questions about our last full time starter, he had character but his intelligence certainly came under extreme scrutiny.