Page 19 of 21
Our Defense
Posted: Wed Sep 02, 2026 7:31 am
by erickench
If we're really gonna run a 3-4 then these depth charts should show it. Our line should consist of Hemingway, Laula, and Fatukasi with Crosby and Paye as our OLBs. Crosby played linebacker in high school. The position is not entirely strange to him.

Re: No franchise has been worse on defense than the Raiders in the last 30 years
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 5:18 am
by chucker
It sure felt like the defense was complete shit, but we only gave up 21 points (a missed FG helped). We were leading at the half. The second half offense was significantly worse than the second half defense. Mendoza's development will hopefully alleviate some of those offensive woes. We just don't have the same easy-to-imagine solutions on defense right now.
Re: No franchise has been worse on defense than the Raiders in the last 30 years
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 5:34 am
by heavyD
It makes one wonder if Mendoza turns out to be really good, if the Raiders will ever be able to build a supporting defense. GM's, coaches, players come and go but the terrible defenses are ever present. Lots of blame to go around as the Raiders historically being one of the worst drafting teams is probably the main culprit as the talent has never been good enough. Results under Spytec haven't been overly encouraging as save from picking a QB at 1OA, there aren't really any players he's drafted that look like they will be difference makers for years to come. Leonard certainly doesn't look like the answer either. Sounds like a broken record but decades come and go and the Raiders are still in the same predicament that they need to draft better and hire better coaches.
Re: No franchise has been worse on defense than the Raiders in the last 30 years
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 5:56 am
by NoThanksSir
Defense played a lot better for one half of football, and then completely collapsed. We saw flashes from guys like Walker and Quay. Maxx had a few TFL's. Tonka and Fatukasi have been solid DT's. I would have to look at the all-22 but I bet our coverage in the first half wasn't that bad either, but those guys can't be expected to cover for as long as they are.
3 QB hits against a Seahawks OL that was down 3 starters is abysmal. Giving Paye that contract and bringing back Koonce has been an unmitigated disaster. Believe me I would love a true NT but until there is another legitimate pass rusher opposite of Maxx this defense is going nowhere.
And public enemy #1 right now should be Eric Stokes. He's not only playing poorly, I question his effort out there. He's giving up completions and his teammates are swooping in for cleanup tackles while he stands there doing absolutely nothing. He completely gave up on that one Lock TD pass. I'm convinced the only reason this guy is still on the field is the abysmal contract we just gave him. Unfortunately we're on the hook with Stokes for $10 mill in 2027, otherwise he should be benched and Porter/McCoy/Masses should be playing. I'd rather lose with young guys trying to be better than a rich vet dogging it out there for the world to see.
Re: No franchise has been worse on defense than the Raiders in the last 30 years
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:33 am
by Attyla
chucker wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 5:18 am
It sure felt like the defense was complete shit, but we only gave up 21 points (a missed FG helped). We were leading at the half. The second half offense was significantly worse than the second half defense. Mendoza's development will hopefully alleviate some of those offensive woes. We just don't have the same easy-to-imagine solutions on defense right now.
They really adjusted to what we were doing. Defensively they put a lot more pressure on the QB and the RB group. Not only just the blitz packages but they really loaded up the box. It felt like they were playing for Mendoza to make mistakes in the first half, very soft with regards to pushing the pocket. Second half they were looking to force mistakes since Mendoza played pretty clean. Offensively, they just decided it was time to pick up the pace with the passing game and we had no answer.
FYI the defense for us? That first TD of theirs was not on the DC, it was on the DB who gave up on the play thinking it was over. Lock completely owned it from there. Masses looked lost and McCoy looked timid. But for all the Maxx haters out there, he had one of his finest games of the year. He was everywhere, maybe not making a tackle but was disruptive as hell. And he got to the point where he personally decided to shut down their run game. It was pretty impressive how he stepped up.
Re: No franchise has been worse on defense than the Raiders in the last 30 years
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:48 am
by NoThanksSir
Attyla wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:33 am
That first TD of theirs was not on the DC, it was on the DB who gave up on the play thinking it was over. Lock completely owned it from there.
Eric f[raiders_icon]cking Stokes. Dude needs to give his game check back, because he didn't show up to work yesterday.
Re: No franchise has been worse on defense than the Raiders in the last 30 years
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:51 am
by pfish57
NoThanksSir wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:48 am
Eric f[raiders_icon]cking Stokes. Dude needs to give his game check back, because he didn't show up to work yesterday.
He should be benched no doubt, and Maxx celebrating after getting gashed all game was nothing less than Pathetic!
Re: No franchise has been worse on defense than the Raiders in the last 30 years
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 8:05 am
by Xramfan
Attyla wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:33 am
They really adjusted to what we were doing. Defensively they put a lot more pressure on the QB and the RB group. Not only just the blitz packages but they really loaded up the box. It felt like they were playing for Mendoza to make mistakes in the first half, very soft with regards to pushing the pocket. Second half they were looking to force mistakes since Mendoza played pretty clean. Offensively, they just decided it was time to pick up the pace with the passing game and we had no answer.
FYI the defense for us? That first TD of theirs was not on the DC, it was on the DB who gave up on the play thinking it was over. Lock completely owned it from there. Masses looked lost and McCoy looked timid. But for all the Maxx haters out there, he had one of his finest games of the year. He was everywhere, maybe not making a tackle but was disruptive as hell. And he got to the point where he personally decided to shut down their run game. It was pretty impressive how he stepped up.
I don’t hate Maxx but I did specifically zone in on him for a series here and a series there like I have the last couple of games. Maybe I have just picked his rough snaps but I saw what I saw. His best bursts he was untouched. When he does get blocked he was doubled a few times but not most and he wasn’t getting off the blocker. Trailing plays he runs sluggish and flatfooted. It’s not the same “Mad Motor” Max I have seen in previous years. Again, I want him to be a game wrecker but the times I watch only him, I’m not impressed.
I will also disclose I missed the entire first half yesterday so my observations began in the second half
Re: No franchise has been worse on defense than the Raiders in the last 30 years
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 8:38 am
by pfish57
Xramfan wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 8:05 am
I don’t hate Maxx but I did specifically zone in on him for a series here and a series there like I have the last couple of games. Maybe I have just picked his rough snaps but I saw what I saw. His best bursts he was untouched. When he does get blocked he was doubled a few times but not most and he wasn’t getting off the blocker. Trailing plays he runs sluggish and flatfooted. It’s not the same “Mad Motor” Max I have seen in previous years. Again, I want him to be a game wrecker but the times I watch only him, I’m not impressed.
I will also disclose I missed the entire first half yesterday so my observations began in the second half
He didn't do shit in the first half;)
Re: No franchise has been worse on defense than the Raiders in the last 30 years
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 9:19 am
by NoThanksSir
Xramfan wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 8:05 am
I don’t hate Maxx but I did specifically zone in on him for a series here and a series there like I have the last couple of games. Maybe I have just picked his rough snaps but I saw what I saw. His best bursts he was untouched. When he does get blocked he was doubled a few times but not most and he wasn’t getting off the blocker. Trailing plays he runs sluggish and flatfooted. It’s not the same “Mad Motor” Max I have seen in previous years. Again, I want him to be a game wrecker but the times I watch only him, I’m not impressed.
I will also disclose I missed the entire first half yesterday so my observations began in the second half
Maxx is still a very good player but I do agree he seems to lack the ability to win outright on pass reps. He was always a high effort/motor guy but as he ages I think it will become more obvious that he's not some elite pass rusher.
Re: No franchise has been worse on defense than the Raiders in the last 30 years
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 9:40 am
by DeathStar24
Stokes deserves his criticism, but how about Koonce actually making a play and bring Locke down? If we all took shots every time a Raider missed a tackle we'd all be embalmed.
Re: No franchise has been worse on defense than the Raiders in the last 30 years
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 9:48 am
by DanKD
Crosby is still a very good player but not elite. That said, the rest of our dline is terrible
Re: No franchise has been worse on defense than the Raiders in the last 30 years
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 9:54 am
by RI RAIDER
I hope we trade Maxx this off season. I do not care what we get for him. Take a look of our highest paid players. I do not think there is a guy earning his paycheck.
Re: No franchise has been worse on defense than the Raiders in the last 30 years
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 10:00 am
by Reno Hightower
It's tough for any defense to hold when the offense engineers 7 straight punts. Defense sucks but wasn't the biggest factor in yesterday's loss.
Re: No franchise has been worse on defense than the Raiders in the last 30 years
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 10:52 am
by Attyla
DeathStar24 wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 9:40 am
Stokes deserves his criticism, but how about Koonce actually making a play and bring Locke down? If we all took shots every time a Raider missed a tackle we'd all be embalmed.
Tackling was horrible but we are continuing to take bad angles which results in us having to tackle guys running away from us. Masses was getting burned but we did not slide a safety to help, and when we did it was not Stukes who is quickly owning every bit of ground he is covering. We really need McCoy to mature into his role because he did show a couple sparks out there, just not great tackling.
Re: No franchise has been worse on defense than the Raiders in the last 30 years
Posted: Mon Nov 16, 2026 3:14 pm
by Rainman56
pfish57 wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:51 am
and Maxx celebrating after getting gashed all game was nothing less than Pathetic!
Yep
