Raiderstation

[quote=CWood24 post_id=1023052]So what you’re saying is that any stat quoted as being a reason for him being re-signed means nothing

Cant throw one stat out & use another

What is most of Carr passing yards are actually three quarters receivers YAC that would mean he isnt a great passers & his receivers have been more than adequate but the stats quoted will never reflect that

Also you cannot say that because he broke his leg he’d have had more playoff appearances than just the 1[/quote]You’re reading way too much into my point. I’m not interested in re-signing Carr (and not “resigning Carr”). All I’m saying is “no playoff games” is misleading. No?

[quote=VEfreak post_id=1023035]I’ve compared him to Dalton for years. It’s a fitting comparison.[/quote]Dalton has been my comparison for Carr too. For a while it was that he could turn out to be really good, or turn out to be Dalton - just good enough to keep his job for too long. Turns out, sadly, that it's the latter.

[quote=Attyla post_id=1022804]still think we are resiging Carr this off season, 5 year deal 35M per[/quote]That would be idiotic. So it's definitely possible.

QB room drama is the last thing I want to see especially since Mariota is such trash. Dude might be good for a game or two if he stays healthy but after that....trash..

I don’t think Mariotta is a good QB by any stretch, but sometimes change for the sake of change is good. Carr hasn’t done anything to get the benefit of the doubt anymore. Let’s see what Mariotta can do the remainder of the season. Maybe it will increase his trade value too, and both QBs can get traded in the offseason.

[quote=sooperkool post_id=1023091]QB room drama is the last thing I want to see especially since Mariota is such trash. Dude might be good for a game or two if he stays healthy but after that....trash..[/quote]It’s not about this season, we’re fubar already this year. It doesn’t matter who starts at this point.

Carr needs to demand a trade. He is rotting away in the worst organization in sports and no QB can succeed here. If I were Carr I would want to be traded to New Orleans and even the Giants.

I get a laugh at everyone thinking QB want to play for this organization. They dont, Why would any talented player want to play for this team.

[quote=Fade2SilverAndBlack post_id=1023055]https://twitter.com/JoshDubowAP/status/ ... 12324?s=20[/quote]7-37 = 44 playoff team games in almost 9 years.
That's about 5 games per season average.
So 16 game season - 5 games vs. playoff teams = 11-5 average strength of schedule using only playoff teams.

Raiders only won 11 games once, so the Raiders rosters must not have been very talented, since they could not go 11-0 vs non-playoff teams.

Can't blame Carr for that stat. Whole team sucked, often.

I say they re-sign to a team friendly deal and attempt to draft his replacement

[quote=BoJacksonRules post_id=1023103]I say they re-sign to a team friendly deal and attempt to draft his replacement[/quote]Why would Carr want to sign a team friendly deal? This is a franchise that wasted 8 years of my career. I would demand more money than Mahomes from this franchise. Just to get me out of town.

Lol. Good luck with that.

[quote=KennyPowers post_id=1023095] If I were Carr I would want to be traded to New Orleans and even the Giants. [/quote]The Giants??? LMAO I'm thinking that's the last place Carr wants to be for a variety of reasons.The puss would be permanently full fetal after 5 games.

[quote=Rainman56 post_id=1023115]The Giants??? LMAO I'm thinking that's the last place Carr wants to be for a variety of reasons.The puss would be permanently full fetal after 5 games.[/quote]The NY media and fan base would have Carr in tears....

[quote=KennyPowers post_id=1023095]Carr needs to demand a trade. He is rotting away in the worst organization in sports and no QB can succeed here. If I were Carr I would want to be traded to New Orleans and even the Giants.

I get a laugh at everyone thinking QB want to play for this organization. They dont, Why would any talented player want to play for this team.[/quote]How much did your Carr purity ring cost? Are they expensive?

[quote=KennyPowers post_id=1023095]Carr needs to demand a trade. He is rotting away in the worst organization in sports and no QB can succeed here. If I were Carr I would want to be traded to New Orleans and even the Giants.

I get a laugh at everyone thinking QB want to play for this organization. They dont, Why would any talented player want to play for this team.[/quote]Tom Brady wanted to play for the Raiders.
https://www.raidersbeat.com/report-tom- ... e-raiders/

Aaron Rodgers wanted to play for the Raiders.
https://foxsportsradio.iheart.com/conte ... in-week-1/

They don't come much more talented than that. These teams might love Carr in September and October, but November forward the honeymoon would end abruptly.